Indemnización por incapacidad laboral permanente y jurisprudencia sobre calificación -ganancial o privativa- de los incrementos dinerarios del salario
-
1
Universidad de Navarra
info
ISSN: 0210-301X
Any de publicació: 2020
Volum: 73
Número: 4
Pàgines: 1807-1822
Tipus: Article
Altres publicacions en: Anuario de derecho civil
Resum
In the decision of December 14, 2017, on the nature –whether common or exclusive– of a «compensation for permanent disability to work», the Supreme Court has modified its only precedent on this topic, the decision of 25 March 1988. In 1988 the court stablished that when the compensation is received while the community of property exists, it should be considered as a labor income and, therefore, as an income of the community of property. On the contrary, the latest decision has stablished that the compensation should be treated as an exclusive income, due to the close relationship between the compensation and the personality and the compensation for personal injures. This change of opinion could undermine the relatively stable Supreme Court case law on the treatment of monetary increases other than salaries, with its patrimonial focus. This paper studies the posible consequences of the recent decisión of the Supreme Court, as well as the reasons that explain its new orientation. The research concludes by nothing that, probably, neither of both solution is fair, since neither of them takes into account the time factor.
Referències bibliogràfiques
- Lacruz Berdejo, José Luis: Elementos de Derecho civil, IV, Derecho de Familia, Barcelona, Bosch, 1984.
- López Cumbre, Lourdes: «Comentario a la STS 14 de diciembre de 2017. Valor privativo o ganancial del complemento empresarial por incapacidad permanente del trabajador», Cuadernos Civitas de Jurisprudencia Civil, n.º 108, sept–dic 2018, pp. 195–215.
- Martínez Escribano, Celia: «Comentario al artículo 1347», en Comentarios al Código Civil (dir. por Andrés Domínguez Luelmo), Valladolid, Lex Nova, 2010, pp. 1488–1491.
- Peña Bernaldo de Quirós, Manuel: Derecho de Familia, Madrid, Publicaciones de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 1989.
- Ragel Sánchez, Luis Felipe: El régimen de gananciales, Cizur Menor, Aranzadi Thomson Reuters, 2017.
- Rams Albesa, Joaquín: La sociedad de gananciales, Madrid, Tecnos, 1992.
- Serrano Fernández, María: «Comentario al art. 1346», en Cañizares Laso, Ana, De Pablo Contreras, Pedro; Orduña Moreno, Javier, y Valpuesta Fernández, Rosario (dir.), Código Civil comentado, III, Cizur Menor, Civitas Thomson Reuters, 2011, p. 958-966.
- Peña Bernaldo de Quirós, Manuel: «Comentario al artículo 1346», en Comentario del Código civil, Madrid, Ministerio de Justicia, 2.ª ed., 1993, pp. 637-644.